Is It Ethical to Use Bark Collars on Dogs?

There are three different types of dog bark collars that are very popular at the moment among dog owners. All these types are extremely efficient, however people wonder whether they are ethical to use or not. If you own a noisy dog, you need to get informed on the options you have available.

Citronella Spray Collars

These no bark collars use a strong citronella smell when the dog barks persistently. Because dogs really don’t like the smell of citrus, this can be very effective as a no bark collar. Some types of citrus spray collars make a hissing sound before spraying the substance, so that the dog can stop barking even sooner once it learns what the hiss means. The dog is not hurt at all by either the sound or the spray.

Collars With Ultrasonic/Sonic Mechanisms

The sound produced by sonic or ultrasonic devices is only heard by dogs. This tone is similar to the dog whistle sound. Usually people do not hear it, but dogs get easily annoyed by the noise and tend to stop barking once they learn this is how they can silence the device. Is this considered ethical by the experts? Yes. Again, the dog feels no pain whatsoever, but it is only annoyed by the noise. Sonic collars are not as efficient as the other bark collars because the dog can easily get used to the sound and ignore it.

Electronic Bark Collars

When the electronic collar “hears” the dog bark, it gives the dog a mild electrical shock. The shock does not threaten the health of the dog and produces a discomfort comparable to the static shocks felt by humans. Once again, mostly just an annoyance - but this is the type of no bark collar that some people believe is unethical. Because the dog can actually feel discomfort due to the shock, some consider it should not be used anymore. Many condemn the use of such devices. Nonetheless, the electronic dog collar is extremely efficient so, if you own a dog that barks all the time, you may consider it a viable solution.

To deter a dog from barking excessively, you can choose from no bark dog collars that use citronella spray, sonic or ultrasonic sounds, or electronic shocking. Citronella spray and sonic or ultrasonic sounds are considered ethical, but electronic shock collars are sometimes considered unethical because of the shocking. All in all, no aforementioned solution is harmful to your dog.

Resource Box

no bark collars have gained more and more popularity lately, because of their efficacy in teaching your dog how to behave. However, some people consider the electronic dog collar unethical, because it uses electronic shocks to calm the barking. It is up to you to choose the most proper method to educate your dog. You should know that no matter which dog collar you choose, it will not harm your dog, but merely annoy it. If you want to read more about no bark dog collars and why they are so safe for your dog’s health, click this link.



Comments are closed.